Team Mendoza

Is Zillow's value what your home is worth? Why the Zestimate misses and how to find the real price

Suburban home with a yard in Metro Detroit

Data last verified: November 19, 2026.

How does Zillow calculate your home's value?

Platforms like Zillow, Realtor.com, Trulia or Movoto use an AVM (Automated Valuation Model). It takes public data:

  • Recent sales in the area.
  • Size of the home and the lot.
  • Number of bedrooms and bathrooms.
  • Information recorded by the county.

From that it estimates a number. Sometimes it lands close to the real value and sometimes it is far off.

How accurate is the Zestimate?

Zillow publishes its own margin of error. According to its Zestimate page (checked on November 10, 2026):

Type of home Median Zestimate error
For sale (on-market) About 1.8%
Not for sale (off-market, the home you own and haven't listed) About 7.2%

"Median error" means that half of the homes have an error greater than that. On a $250,000 home, a 7% error is about $17,500, which can be the difference between selling fast or leaving money on the table. Zillow has been changing these numbers over time, so treat them as an order of magnitude. And the low margin for homes on the market doesn't apply to your home before you list it: there, the error is the highest.

Why can the estimate be wrong?

Because the algorithm never walks into the home. It doesn't know:

  • Whether the kitchen is remodeled or original from 40 years ago.
  • Whether there is moisture, roof damage or structural problems.
  • The quality of materials and recent upgrades.
  • The exact location: two homes on the same block can be worth different amounts because of the view, noise or lot size.

¿El valor que ves en Zillow o Realtor.com es realmente lo que vale tu casa?Watch on YouTube · 4 min

Zestimate vs. CMA: which one should you use to set a price?

Online estimate (AVM) Comparative market analysis (CMA)
Who does it An algorithm An agent who knows the area
Do they visit the home? No Yes
Considers upgrades and condition No Yes
Compares with real nearby sales Generally Yes, home by home with adjustments
Cost Free Free with Team Mendoza

How do I find my home's real value?

Ask for a CMA: we compare your home with those sold over the last year, those under contract and those competing today, adjusting for condition and upgrades. That is how we set a price that attracts buyers without leaving money on the table.

¿Qué es un CMA y por qué es clave para vender tu casa en USAWatch on YouTube · 5 min Thinking about selling? Read our guide to selling your home in Michigan. And if you are buying, see how the bank's appraisal works in our step-by-step buying guide.

Frequently asked questions

How accurate is the Zestimate?

According to Zillow, the median error is about 2% on homes for sale and about 7% on homes that are not on the market. It can come close to the real value in areas with many similar sales, but it misses a lot when the home has upgrades, problems or an unusual location, because the algorithm doesn't visit the property.

Does the bank use Zillow's value?

No. For a loan, the bank orders an appraisal done by an independent appraiser who visits the home.

What is the difference between a Zestimate and an appraisal?

A Zestimate is calculated by an algorithm from public data and doesn't visit the home. An appraisal is done by a licensed appraiser who does visit it, and the bank uses it to decide how much to lend. A CMA is done by an agent to set the sale price.

How much does it cost to find out my home's real value?

Nothing. We do a comparative market analysis for free and with no obligation.

Andreina Mendoza

REALTOR® in Michigan with RE/MAX Leading Edge. Law degree (UCAB, 2015).

Want to talk about your situation?

We'll walk you through it in a free consultation, in English or Spanish.

Book a callMessage us on WhatsApp